“We are in very dangerous times, of
mobs and meaninglessness. People aren’t swayed by facts anymore; they’re
indifferent to reality and openly scornful of experts.
“All they want is to feel
good, even if it’s only for an instant, even if it’s at the cost of an entire
future. Vast
crowds of the pleasure-hungry are being pulled along into increasingly
destructive politics by cheap sound bites and tawdry emotion.
“We’re teetering
over the edge, and people hardly even notice—it’s all become theater; society
rips itself apart in real time before our eyes, but we approach it like an
entertainment product… This is madness, but it’s also what’s come to rule our
world. You’ve probably heard the name for all this. We are in post-truth
politics…
“We
have always been in post-truth politics. The first written texts of political
theory are a lament that questions of government are no longer ruled by
transcendent, objective fact. So many subsequent interventions tend to carry
the same theme.
“John
Stuart Mill and Alexis de Tocqueville warned darkly of the ignorant masses on
the horizons, now terrifyingly sovereign. Kant saw humanity living deeply
irrational lives in a state of self-imposed nonage, capable of being rescued
only by an enlightened but autocratic
ruler.
“Most revealingly, in his Reflections
on the Revolution in France, Edmund Burke condemns radical and
nonconformist preachers, who use their pulpits ‘not for the diffusion of truth,
but for the spreading of contradiction.’
“Whenever
political processes start to involve large numbers of people, there’s a worry
that truth is being abandoned. This ought to say something. Science is a
discourse in which the categories of truth or falsehood make sense; aesthetics
is one in which they don’t.
“Politics
is something strange, however: It’s far closer to literature than it is to science—disagreements
over political principle can’t be settled through a practical experiment—but
for nearly two and a half thousand years it’s faced the criticism that it
should be something different from what it is…
“Politics
is where people can gain the ability to actively reshape the world, rather than
just describe it. It’s as false as the Athenian theater, and this is no bad
thing. Of course these aspects of politics can give rise to monsters like
Donald Trump; dreams always raise the possibility of a nightmare.
“But when
we’re confronted with political evil, our response should be to fight it with
something good, not to grumble that it’s getting its statistics wrong...”
from
The Biggest Political Lie of 2016 by
Sam Kriss.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.