“Sarah Blaine, a lawyer and mother in New Jersey, took
the 4th grade PARCC sample test. She has a daughter in 4th grade. Blaine was
outraged by the test questions. She wrote
a letter to the members of Governor Christie’s PARCC Task Force and urged
them to take the test before they make their recommendations” (Diane Ravitch’s Blog).
"She writes: ‘…I have a fourth grade daughter. She was
first identified for our district’s gifted and talented program for English
Language Arts in kindergarten, as she came into kindergarten reading chapter
books. Her vocabulary and analysis skills remain quite advanced for a child of
her age. And I can tell you that she retains the ability to imagine.
"Do you
remember that, the ability to imagine with ease? Do you remember your
childhood, when you could create imaginary worlds and people them with
imaginary characters just by wishing them into existence? Do you remember building
forts and castles that were as real to you as could be?
"For a moment, for just
a moment, I ask you to call upon what is likely your long-stagnated power of
imagination. Imagine yourself at nine or ten years old. Imagine your room,
imagine your friends, and imagine your school work.
"Then sit down. Keep yourself in your nine or ten year
old mindset. Boot up your desktop, or power up your laptop, or unlock your
iPad. Navigate to the PARCC website at http://www.parcconline.org/.
"Navigate to the 4th grade English Language Arts PARCC practice test. Open it in
front of you, right now, as you read this comment. If you refuse to sit down to
take the sample tests yourself, then with all due respect I submit that farcical
as this task force — with its 6 week window to issue recommendations — might
be, you are not meeting your obligation as member of this task force.
"Remember
as you work through the 4th grade PARCC practice test that you are not your
current self — you are still your nine or ten year old self…’
"Can you truly look me in the eye and tell me with a
straight face that this is an appropriate task for our children? Now can you
truly look me in the eye and tell me in all honesty that a child who cannot
succeed on this task is not on track for college or a career?
"Now, can you
truly look me in the eye and tell me as if you mean it that preparing our
children for this work is what their teachers should be spending the year
doing? Now, can you truly look me in the eye and tell me that your child self
would believe that this test was fair and would not give up before the end?
"Now, can you truly look me in the eye and tell me with sincerity that years
spent preparing for tests like these aren’t going to suck the joy, imagination,
love of learning, and creativity out of children — and their teachers?...”
The entire letter
can be found at parentingthecore.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.