"…1.
Americans won’t ever be happy with public education until they understand that
education and job training are two different things, and that we can’t have a
functional democracy and market economy—the two most intellectually demanding
forms of society imaginable—without the sort of education that historically has
done the most to produce sound thinking—a traditional liberal arts education
that develops the whole intellect.
"2.
The reformers will continue their pernicious campaigns until we abandon the
childish fantasy that education can be done cheaply, painlessly, and
effortlessly by some technical fix. Having earned two degrees in chemistry and
a law degree, and having taught my own children as well as the children of
others, I know that learning any subject is an intensely personal experience.
Good teachers are more like good coaches than sales persons or entertainers.
The idea that we can substitute pedagogical training for mastery of actual
subject matter, or that filmstrips, radio, television, movies, or computers, or
whatever whiz-bang technology comes next can be substituted for actual
intellectual engagement between a teacher-master and a student is nothing but
charlatanism. We—parents, school boards, and tax payers—have to start saying
“no” to the self-proclaimed experts (reformers) who are nothing but shills for
corporations that seek to insert their proboscis into the tax revenue stream…"
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.