A federal judge on Thursday ordered President Donald
Trump’s administration to release full funding for 42 million Americans’ Supplemental
Nutrition Assistance Program benefits by Friday, but the US Department
of Justice swiftly filed an appeal.
“I have never seen an American president so desperate to
force children and
seniors to go hungry,” said Senate Appropriations Committee Vice Chair Patty
Murray (D-Wash.). “Donald
Trump is appealing a federal court’s order requiring him to pay the
full SNAP benefits
for this month. This is as ugly and cruel as it gets.”
Unrig Our Economy campaign director Leor Tal similarly
slammed the administration, saying: “Families have already suffered enough,
going nearly a week without SNAP. They don’t deserve all of this whiplash
from Republicans over
the food they
need to survive.”
“Republicans have caused the longest-ever government
shutdown by refusing to permanently extend cost-saving healthcare tax
credits that millions of Americans rely on to afford health coverage,” Tal
said. “Now, they are fighting tooth and nail to avoid fully funding SNAP and
feeding hungry families and children. Who does that? We
need Republicans in Congress to
restore full SNAP benefits now, save Americans’
healthcare, and end the government shutdown.”
Judge John McConnell, appointed to the District of Rhode
Island by former President Barack Obama,
previously gave the
US Department of Agriculture a
choice between making a partial payment by emptying a contingency fund or fully
covering food stamps with that funding plus money from other sources. The USDA opted for the former and warned that it could take weeks to get reduced SNAP benefits to
recipients, millions of whom would lose the
monthly food aid altogether.
Then, on Tuesday, Trump suggested that the administration would not disperse
SNAP benefits until congressional Democrats voted to end what has become the
longest government shutdown in US history. Although White House Press
Secretary Karoline Leavitt later claimed that “the administration is fully complying
with the court order” and “the president is referring to future SNAP payments.”
That same day, lawyers for the municipalities,
nonprofits, and labor groups
behind the lawsuit that led to McConnell’s initial ruling—one of two SNAP cases
currently in the federal court system—filed an emergency request seeking further relief.
On Thursday, McConnell concluded that the USDA’s plan ran
afoul of his previous directive and issued the new oral ruling. He
reportedly said: “Last weekend, SNAP benefits lapsed for the first
time in our nation’s history. This is a problem that could have and should have
been avoided.”
“The defendants failed to consider the practical
consequences associated with this decision to only partially fund SNAP,” the
judge declared. “They knew that there would be a long delay in
paying partial SNAP payments and failed to consider the harms individuals who
rely on those benefits would suffer.”
Despite the White House’s attempted clarification,
McConnell also said that Trump’s post “stated his intent to defy the court
order.”
Before the appeal, the new order was widely celebrated,
including by Democracy Forward
president and CEO Skye Perryman, whose group is representing the plaintiffs
with the Lawyers’ Committee for Rhode Island. She said in a statement that “today is a major victory for
42 million people in America.”
“The court could not be clearer—the Trump-Vance
administration must stop playing politics with people’s lives by delaying SNAP
payments they are obligated to issue,” Perryman continued. “This immoral and
unlawful decision by the administration has shamefully delayed SNAP payments,
taking food off the table of hungry families.”
“We shouldn’t have to force the president to care for his
citizens, but we will do whatever is necessary to protect people and
communities,” she added. “We are honored to represent our brave clients and to
have secured this major victory for those who deserve better than what this
administration has done to them.”
US
House Agriculture Committee Ranking Member Angie Craig (D-Minn.) also
welcomed the order, while ripping Trump and his secretary of agriculture,
Brooke Rollins. The congresswoman stressed: “As we’ve said from the beginning, the Trump
administration has the money and the power to fully fund SNAP in
November. They chose to ignore the harm caused by their actions and cut
benefits instead.”
“President Trump and USDA need to do the right thing and
comply with the court ruling rather than further delay food assistance from
reaching 42 million Americans in need,” she argued. “It is truly shocking and
demoralizing just how far President Trump and Agriculture Secretary Brooke
Rollins have gone to take food out of the mouths of American children, seniors,
working parents, veterans,
and people with disabilities.”
-Jessica Corbett, Common Dreams









